She wasn't very out going. She was pretty reserved. I mean Cap. Kirk didn't even realize she was dating that other dude. Don't want to give the movie away.
I am liking that line of reasoning better. Sometimes it is hard to type with a strict 4 letter combo. She is definetly a feeler if only cause she emphasized with Spock on the deaths. Bold, driven, organized so I say J. I maintain a mild I/E only because she did go out and socialize, etc..
So you're saying that Picard's Ti is not that well developed therefore he became fustrated and had no imagination to defeat the villain.
Making him a dumb ass.
Kirk would not say that.. He just gets bored. Not incensed.
I retract my statements of the first type assessment.. Kirk remains consistently ENTP..
Point of order: Intuition caused him to detect the Romulan attack during sleep.
He also is revered by his CO for intelligence, ability and a reckless nature.. This is more ENTx than ESTx..
The man remains ENTP.. Crazy as they are, they are also quite clever.. I maintain the type dynamic between himself and Spock is ENTP/INTJ
Uhura is INFJ, not INTJ.. She is not overtly emotional, that is true, but she is very competent, intuitive and has a strong dignity.. She does not use logic to a significant degree to validate a strong T, rather a more concentrated balance of Ni and Fe.. This reflects in her abilities.
Worf: ISTJ. Not N or F. Very I and J. Takes his duty and rituals very seriously.
Picard: INTJ. Decisive, introspective, ironic. His Ni is evident in his arguments, such as the ones with Q.
Spock: I'd say INT. Gravitates between J and P. But mostly P.
Scotty: Seems a bit NFP to me, but with a strong SP side.
Troi: INFJ
New Kirk: ESTP all the way.
Old Kirk: ENFP I'd say
Uhura: She seems SJ to me. Probably F. I/E hard to tell.
Bones: I think ESFJ.
Q: ENT. Moreso J than P, but the line is close.
Beverly Crusher: Pretty distinguished ISFJ
Wes Crusher: Seems like an IxFP. Moreso N than S.
Tasha Yar: She seems quite ISTP.
Ensign Ro: Hawt. I think ISTP as well. Maaaybe INTJ.
Data: xNTP.
Lore(Data's Evil Twin): ENTx
LaForge: Not sure what he is. Seems like an ENTJ. Struggles with interpersonal relations at times, very "out of the box" and seems to have an erotomania thing going with his ship, which to me screams NT.
to single out one episode to prove a character´s personality isn´t right, as fictional ones can be anything at some points, you have to judge by the big picture and their consistency.
picard is estj all the way. he has alot of fact knowledge but he rarely goes in deep discussions. q is more exception. and riker is esfp, quite likeable (spelling*), laid back but follows the rules and ethics.
data i´ve seen been characterized as intp, i suppose because he is quite open to new ideas and impressions and likes to go along with new experiences (go along, because others need to motivate).
wesley crusher is infp all the way
cpt janeway of voyager is entj
spock must be intj, wat too dutiful for a p
scotty is a bit too cheerfull among strangers to be intp, so i´m guessing extrovert in the old series, but introvert in the movie
Come on guys Captain Picard as an extrovert? He is the most reserved Captain of them all, people seem to aggravate him more than anything, which suggests his energy is taxed when dealing with people. He has a strong sense of duty, which suggests either a NF or SJ variant. He enjoys reading books of philosophy, which suggests iNtuition. He is a very hard character to type, but I would label him as an INFJ. Which makes sense because I think his go to officer is Dianna Troi, who, and I don't think anyone would argue, is text book INFJ in every sense of the type.
Captain Kirk has sex with a lot of aliens, that's all I'm going to say about him.
As for the other species in star trek, each race seems to be a temperament.
Vulcans = NT
Klingons = SJ with a little SP (because of their lust for battle)
Romulans = Extremely intelligent SPs
And most of the protagonist humans seem to be NFs, whereas the antagonist humans seem to be SJs.
I believe the reason why there is so much controversy in they way these characters are typed is because the character is usually the writers representation of the character. So if it is an NT writer the characters might go through an NT trend. NF writers might portrait a more NF set of characters, and so on and so forth. It really depends on the writer/s of the episode/movie.
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Related Threads
?
?
?
?
?
Personality Cafe
10.9M posts
165.6K members
Since 2008
A forum community dedicated to all ranges of personality types and people. Come join the discussion about health, behavior, care, testing, personality types, and more!