This is a discussion on Marvel Avengers within the Guess the type forums, part of the What's my personality type? category; Originally Posted by Fuzbal I have heard that Iron man, or tony stark is an ENTJ and I would agree. ...
Iron Man: ENTJ Tony Stark - MBTI in Fiction (My Favorite)
Captain America: ESFJ Captain America (Steve Rogers) - MBTI in Fiction
Thor: ESFP Thor - MBTI in Fiction
Banner: INTP Bruce Banner - MBTI in Fiction
Black Widow: ISTP Black Widow - MBTI in Fiction
Hawkeye: ISFP Clint Barton aka Hawkeye - MBTI in Fiction
Loki: INFJ Loki - MBTI in Fiction
Tony Stark/ Iron Man is an ENTP without a doubt, all that arrogance :P
Nick Fury: ENTJ
Steve Rogers: ISFJ
Bruce Banner/Hulk: INTJ/ESFP
Tony Stark: ENTP
Natasha Romanoff: ISTP
Clint Barton: ISFP
Agent Phil Coulson: INFP
Maria Hill: ISTJ
Pepper Potts: ISFJ
Dr Erik Selvig: ENFJ
I'm not that certain on Banner or Coulson but Hulk, Black Widow, and Thor I am fairly certain.
According to Beren's interaction style (which I think matches to the Hogwarts Houses)
Gryffindor (Get Things Going/Sanguine): Hulk, Iron Man, Thor
Ravenclaw (Chart The Course/Ravenclaw): Banner, Black Widow, Loki, Hill, Jarvis
Slytherin (In Charge/Choleric): Fury, Selvig
Hufflepuff (Behind The Scenes/Phlegmatic): Captain America, Hawkeye, Potts, Coulson
I see Captain America as either Gryffindor/Hufflepuff while Hill could be Ravenclaw/Slytherin.
I didn't mean to imply that you do, my point was rather some of the explanations don't appear to take into account that there are multiple cognitive causes for behaviour. I mistook your "my favourite" as saying it is your favourite fictional typing blog rather than ENTP is your favourite type or Iron Man is your favourite Avenger.
I do agree with Pepper being an ISFJ with a strong T which probably developed in working in a male dominated corporate atmosphere.
Note: I think the thing with the Hulk is that he is very much id driven and that he's very unpredictable so I could see STP. He is most likely SP but the other letters could be anything.
Or if we assume that the shadow functions come out when we are stressed then the Hulk could be comprised of Banner's shadow functions.
If Banner is an INTJ then his weakest function in the stack of 8, the one that is most unconscious would be Si then Fe then Ti then Ne. That could mean if his most subconscious is Hulk's strongest then the Hulk would be an Unhealthy ISFJ, if his most conscious after his inferior is his strongest than the hulk is a non-vocal, crude, ENTP which could work due to the Hulk's supposed creativity and "lack of focus" and forethought.
If Banner is an INTP, Hulk could be ISFP or ENTJ.
Or if we assume the Hulk is a mirror rather than a shadow of Banner, due to the idea that the gamma radiation gave a visible side to his psychic splitting leaving the meek Banner and the Angrier Hulk which was more forceful (becoming the green rage monster AFTER the experiment).
Banner INTJ, Hulk ESFP
Banner INTP, Hulk ESFJ
ISFJ/ESFJ/ENTJ don't seem plausible, ISFP/ESFP/ENTP is left. Is he more like Hawkeye, Thor, Iron Man (albeit with cruder tools)?
Also I think Coulson could also be INFJ, doesn't seem to cut loose often (Se)
Iron Man - In the movies with Robert Downey Jr he's played as an ENTP but that's becasue Robert Downey Jr is an ENTP and he basically played himself in those movies, But I think in the comics he's more ISTPish
Captain America - Probably ESTJ or ISTJ
Hulk - ISFP, Bruce Banner INTJ
Thor - ESTP
Black Widow - Don't know but maybe either ISTP or ISFP
Hawkeye - ??
Nick Fury - ??
Loki - INTJ, agreed
It seems we currently are experiencing a number of random issues with the forum. These could include: ghost private messages, incorrectly dated PMs, old PMs becoming unread, phantom notifications, deleted accounts, etc.Bear with us while we figure out what is going on. If you have any issue to report, please do so in the support forum. Don\'t panic!