Sorry for the bump, I know this is an old thread, but I found a relevant example.
Edgar Cayce & David Wilcock (Respectively,)
These two guys have very similar if not the exact same astrological construction. David Wilcox believes he is the reincarnation of Edgar Cayce.
I can't give you guys much information because I haven't looked into it (in depth) yet, but a book has been written about it, and I was wondering if this gave some credibility to my argument/astrology in general, you guys can look into it if you want to.
(I assume you guys looked into this thread because you were interested in the topic and didn't just want to tell me "Astrology is bull".)
Here is the book.